You Accepted an Offer. Now the 47 Small Fires Start.

by The Jones Team

 

Under contract?

Now the fun part.

By Jenny Jones, The Jones Team Realtors at Baird & Warner  ·  Last reviewed November 21, 2026

The sign flips to Under Contract. Everybody exhales. You start mentally packing. And I have to be the one to tell you: that wasn’t the finish line. That was the starting gun.

People see the sign, the lockbox, and the handshake at closing. They don’t see the inspection back-and-forth, the lender asking for “just one more document,” or the title company turning up a lien from 2009 that nobody remembered. I like to say a typical sale has 47 small fires. The number is a joke. The fires are not.

The Short Version

After you accept an offer, the buyer’s inspection, the lender’s appraisal and underwriting, the title search, and your contract deadlines all run at the same time. Your agent handles most of it quietly, but a handful of decisions are yours: how to answer repair requests, what to do about a low appraisal, whether to fix a title problem, and whether to agree to a date change. Your signed contract, not some universal Illinois rule, sets the clock on every one of them.

Why the clock starts fast in Algonquin

In recent local sales data for Algonquin (all home types sold August through October 2026), the median home went under contract in 13 days, and those 132 sales closed at an average of 99.6% of list price. The median sale price in that stretch was about $414,700.

So what? Fast contracts at near-list prices mean the price you agreed to is a real number. When an inspection or appraisal tries to move it, that conversation deserves care, not a knee-jerk yes or no.

The inspection: a request is not an order

The inspector reports on the house. The buyer decides what to ask for. You decide how to respond. Unless your contract gives the buyer a specific termination or remedy right, you can generally accept, reject, or counter.

After 20+ years, I can tell you a 40-page report is not 40 problems. Most of it is a house being a house. A few items carry real weight: safety, water, major systems, structure. The skill is sorting those from the noise and answering the thing the buyer actually cares about. A smart counter keeps deals together. A flat “no” to everything can turn a $400 issue into a deadline standoff.

The appraisal: a negotiation, not an automatic price cut

Say your house goes under contract at $425,000 and appraises at $410,000. The lender bases the loan on the lower number, so somebody has to solve a $15,000 gap. The price could come down, the buyer could bring more cash, either side could push for a reconsideration with better comparable sales, or the buyer could exit if the contract allows it.

You are not automatically required to drop the price. You are required to read your contract and make a deliberate choice. This is where real local comps matter more than any online estimate, and where a lot of my quiet work happens before the appraiser ever shows up.

Meanwhile, the lender and the title company are busy

The lender keeps underwriting long after the inspection is done. The buyer has to receive the Closing Disclosure at least three business days before closing, so if that document gets delayed or corrected, the date can slide even when everyone else is ready.

The title company can turn up liens, unpaid taxes, easements, recording errors, or problems from a prior sale. If something needs fixing, you may need to supply payoff letters or documents. Title is the quietest fire, and you usually don’t see it until it matters.

One Algonquin quirk: the village sits in both McHenry and Kane Counties. Which one your house is in affects recording and county-level paperwork, including transfer tax stamps. I want that confirmed on day one so nobody is guessing in week four.

Which decisions are actually yours

What comes up Where it comes from Your options
Inspection request Buyer and their inspector Accept, reject, or counter with a repair, credit, or price change
Low appraisal Buyer’s lender Adjust price, ask buyer to cover the gap, request reconsideration, or face termination if the contract allows
Financing delay Buyer’s lender Have your attorney review extension options before agreeing to anything
Title issue Title commitment Fix it with a payoff, document, or recording so closing can happen
Closing date change Lender, closing agent, county Agree in writing, or hold to the contract

Where people get tripped up

“A request means I have to.” It doesn’t. It means you have to respond, on time, on purpose.

“Dates are flexible.” Until they aren’t. Missed notice deadlines quietly erase options.

“Illinois has one standard timeline.” Nope. Your contract has your timeline. The internet has someone else’s.

What this doesn’t mean

None of this means your deal is fragile. Most contracts in our market make it to the closing table. It also doesn’t mean you fight every request or cave on every one. The goal is knowing which fires are small, which are real, and which ones are yours to put out. (And if a deal does fall apart, here’s what to look at before you relist.)

Your One Thing

The day your offer is accepted, put every date from your contract on a calendar and send it to your agent.

Thinking about selling?

The best time to figure out which fires your house is likely to have is before you list, not after you’re under contract. That’s a conversation we can actually have.

Book a strategy sessionFree consultation

Questions people actually ask

What happens after my Algonquin home offer is accepted?

Several things start at once: inspection, appraisal and underwriting, title search, and any attorney review or HOA document review. Each has its own deadline in your contract. Your agent tracks them so you only decide the items that are truly yours.

Can the buyer cancel after the inspection?

Only if your contract gives them a termination or remedy right within the inspection window. Otherwise you can generally accept, reject, or counter their requests.

Do I have to lower my price if the appraisal is low?

No. It becomes a negotiation. The price could change, the buyer could bring cash, someone could request a reconsideration, or the buyer could exit if the contract allows it.

Can closing be pushed back if the buyer’s loan is delayed?

Yes, if both sides agree in writing. A delay doesn’t automatically end the contract. Have your attorney look at notice and extension terms before you sign anything.

Which closing costs are negotiable?

Repair credits and the split of some closing items are commonly negotiated. Taxes set by law are fixed, but who pays them is usually set in the contract. Check yours.

About The Jones Team Realtors

The Jones Team has been helping people buy and sell homes across the Fox River Valley since 1976. That’s 2,482 recorded transaction sides and $588,853,034 in combined lifetime sales volume (as of November 2026). Our history runs deepest in Carpentersville, Elgin, West Dundee, Algonquin, Sleepy Hollow, East Dundee, Lake in the Hills, Huntley, Crystal Lake, and Gilberts.

Meet the team:

The Jones Team Realtors at Baird & Warner · 1557 S. Randall Rd, Algonquin, IL 60102 · 847.654.9776 · jonesteamhomes.com

Curious how past clients felt about working with us? Read our reviews on Google and Zillow.

Sources: Illinois REALTORS market stats · Illinois Department of Revenue, Real Estate Transfer Tax · Angelillo Law, Kane County residential real estate · Local Algonquin sales data, August to October 2026. Last reviewed November 21, 2026.

This article is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Confirm your own numbers and contract rights with your attorney, lender, or tax advisor. Information provided is not guaranteed and subject to change and withdrawal without notice. This publication is not intended to solicit the listing of properties currently under contract with other real estate professionals. We do business in accordance with the Federal Fair Housing Act and the Illinois Human Rights Act. Equal Housing Opportunity. Jenny Jones, Team Leader & Broker Associate, Baird & Warner, 1557 S. Randall Rd, Algonquin, IL 60102. IL License 471.001637.

The Jones Team
The Jones Team

It's EASIER to Move When The Jones Team Has Your Back!

+1(224) 622-3237 | jones.team@bairdwarner.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message